The Limits on Mandatory Protection and No-Contact Orders Under Colorado Civil and Criminal Law

COLORADO CRIMINAL LAWYER BLOG • DOMESTIC VIOLENCE / PROTECTION ORDERS

What a Colorado court can order, what it cannot, and how to challenge an order that goes too far

By H. Michael Steinberg, Denver Criminal Defense Lawyer  |  November 18, 2026

Every week in Denver courtrooms, people walk out of a first appearance carrying a piece of paper that changes their lives. It tells them they cannot go home. It tells them they cannot speak to their spouse, sometimes not even to their own children. It tells them to surrender their firearms within days. Most of them assume the order is absolute — that a judge can write anything into it, for as long as the judge likes.

That assumption is wrong. In more than forty years of defending Coloradans charged with domestic violence and other crimes, I have seen protection orders used appropriately, and I have seen them stretched far beyond what the law allows. Colorado’s protection order statutes are powerful, but they have edges — statutory limits written by the General Assembly and constitutional limits enforced by our appellate courts. This article maps those edges for both the criminal mandatory protection order (MPO) and the civil protection order.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • A criminal MPO under C.R.S. § 18-1-1001 may protect only victims and witnesses — and after HB 25-1148, it cannot be used to impose bond conditions or protect the defendant from himself.
  • An MPO ends at final disposition of the case — which, for a sentenced defendant, means completion of the sentence, including parole.
  • When a no-contact order keeps a parent from a child, the court must find compelling circumstances and that no less restrictive means will work — People v. Zoller and People v. Manzanares.
  • Civil orders under Title 13, Article 14 require proof that the conduct will continue unless restrained; a restrained party must generally wait two years to seek modification.
  • The protected person’s consent is not a defense to a violation — only the court can change its own order.

Two Separate Systems: Criminal MPOs and Civil Protection Orders

Colorado law expressly creates two tracks. The legislative declaration in C.R.S. § 13-14-100.2 calls for “a simplified civil process and a mandatory criminal process.” They overlap, they are frequently in force at the same time against the same person, and both are enforced through the same crime — violation of a protection order, C.R.S. § 18-6-803.5. But they are created differently, they last for different periods, and they are changed by different procedures.

The criminal and civil tracks have different triggers, durations, and modification rules.
FeatureCriminal MPO (§ 18-1-1001)Civil Order (§§ 13-14-104.5, -106)
How it startsAutomatically when a person is charged and advised at first appearanceA petitioner files a verified complaint
Who is protectedVictims and witnesses onlyThe petitioner (and others named, such as children)
Standard of proofNone — it attaches by operation of lawTemporary: imminent danger. Permanent: preponderance + likely to continue
How long it lastsUntil final disposition (sentence completion)Temporary until hearing; permanent may be indefinite
Who may seek modificationDefendant, at any time; prosecutor on victim’s behalfProtected party any time; restrained party after 2 years

The Criminal Mandatory Protection Order Under C.R.S. § 18-1-1001

Under C.R.S. § 18-1-1001(1), a mandatory protection order is created against any person charged with a Title 18 offense. It takes effect when the defendant is advised of rights at arraignment or first appearance. No one has to ask for it, and no evidence has to be presented. The baseline order prohibits the defendant from harassing, molesting, intimidating, retaliating against, or tampering with any witness or victim. In most cases the court then adds a full no-contact provision and often an order to stay away from the shared home. The order is entered on the standardized JDF 440 form.

Limit #1: The Order Ends at Final Disposition

The MPO is tied to the life of the criminal case. It remains in effect until final disposition — and § 18-1-1001(8)(b) defines that point, for a defendant who is sentenced, as the completion of the sentence. In People v. Zoller, the Court of Appeals noted that for a defendant sentenced to prison, final disposition arrives only on discharge from parole supervision. If the charges are dismissed or the defendant is acquitted, the case is over and the order ends with it.

A critical warning: do not decide for yourself that an order has expired. In People v. Delfeld, 2021 COA, the defendant argued his MPO should have been void because his underlying sentence was illegal. The Court of Appeals disagreed. Until a court actually vacates the conviction, enters a new sentence, or modifies or dismisses the order, the MPO stays in force — and the defendant’s new conviction for violating it stood.

An MPO runs from first appearance to completion of the sentence — with two key windows to change it.

Limit #2: The Defendant May Seek Modification at Any Time

The court retains jurisdiction to enforce, modify, or dismiss the order until final disposition, and the defendant may move to modify or dismiss at any time — § 18-1-1001(3)(a)(I). In domestic violence, stalking, and unlawful sexual behavior cases, the prosecutor may also request a hearing to modify the order, typically at the protected person’s request, with notice to the victim. Practically, that means a defense lawyer can — and often should — ask early to allow limited contact for shared parenting, the retrieval of belongings, or communication through counsel.

HB 25-1148: The Legislature Drew New Lines Around MPOs

In 2025 the General Assembly passed HB 25-1148 (Session Law, Chapter 154), which took effect July 1, 2025, and applies to protection orders issued for offenses committed on or after that date. For the first time, the statute itself says what an MPO is not allowed to do. The changes are among the most significant limits on criminal protection orders in a generation.

HB 25-1148 confined criminal MPOs to their core purpose: protecting victims and witnesses.
  • Victims and witnesses only. The order is limited to protecting victims or witnesses. Additional orders may not be aimed at the charged offense itself, and the court may not enter orders to protect the defendant — including from his own substance use.
  • No bond conditions smuggled into the MPO. Pretrial release conditions belong in the bond order under C.R.S. § 16-4-105, not in the protection order. That distinction matters because a protection order violation is a separate crime.
  • Alcohol and drug restrictions need a nexus. A sobriety term requires a sufficient connection to the safety of a victim or witness, or — in domestic violence and listed-crime cases — a finding that the restriction is appropriate for safety.
  • The catch-all needs imminent danger. The open-ended “any other order” provision now requires a finding that it is necessary to protect against imminent danger to the protected person’s life or health.
  • Mandatory review at sentencing. Under the new § 18-1-1001(6.5), at sentencing (or other resolution), the court must review each provision for accuracy, consider modification, and may dismiss the order where it is no longer necessary — except in domestic violence and listed-crime cases.

PRACTICE NOTE: THE OTHER SIDE OF HB 25-1148

The same bill tightened enforcement. A sentence for violating a protection order in a domestic violence or listed-crime case must run consecutively to the sentence for the underlying crime, and violating an order’s alcohol or drug prohibition is now expressly a violation under § 18-6-803.5. At the same time, officers were given discretion — rather than a mandatory-arrest duty — for certain lower-level violations in non-domestic cases.

Constitutional Limits: The Right to Family Association

The most important judicial limit on no-contact orders comes from the Due Process Clause. A parent’s right to the care and companionship of his or her child is a fundamental right. When a protection order cuts a parent off from a child, the order must survive heightened scrutiny — and Colorado’s appellate courts have been increasingly explicit about what that requires.

  • People v. Cooley, 2020 COA 101 — before imposing a supervision condition that prohibited familial contact, the trial court needed a record finding of compelling circumstances.
  • People v. Zoller, 2023 COA 117 — the first Colorado case to apply the test to an MPO. When a defendant moves to modify an MPO that infringes on the right to parental association, the court may not deny the motion without finding (1) compelling circumstances and (2) that the purpose cannot be accomplished by less restrictive means. The denial was reversed.
  • Salah v. People, 2024 CO 54 — the Colorado Supreme Court held that for extended family (there, a nephew), the threshold question is the nature of the relationship; a biological connection alone is not enough.
  • People v. Manzanares, 2025 COA 62 — a legal parent with intact parental rights does not have to first prove a substantial relationship with his own children. The court must make the Zoller findings, and the case was remanded to re-examine the order’s scope.

“A no-contact order that separates a parent from a child is not a routine form to be checked. It is an infringement on one of the oldest fundamental rights we recognize, and the court must justify it on the record.”
— H. Michael Steinberg

The Zoller/Manzanares framework — each step requires a specific finding on the record.

Less restrictive alternatives are often available: supervised parenting time, contact limited to letters or a parenting app, exchanges through a third party, or an exception for court-ordered family therapy. When a motion to modify is litigated well, the record will show the court exactly which alternatives were proposed and why — or whether — each was rejected.

First Amendment Limits on No-Contact Orders

A protection order restrains conduct directed at a protected person. It is not a general license to punish speech about that person. The Colorado Supreme Court in People v. Moreno, 2022 CO 15, struck down a portion of the harassment statute as substantially overbroad, and the U.S. Supreme Court in Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023), required proof of at least recklessness before speech can be punished as a true threat. Those cases do not invalidate no-contact orders, but they inform how broadly an order — and a charged violation — can be read.

Courts generally interpret protection orders as limits on contact, not on public expression.

In July 2026, the Tenth Circuit in Drexler v. Weiser rejected a long-running federal challenge to Colorado’s civil protection order scheme in part because the order at issue, by its own terms, did not restrict the restrained person’s First Amendment activity.

When a prosecution rests on a social media post or a public statement rather than a communication directed to the protected person, the scope of the order’s language — and the First Amendment — become central defense questions.

Civil Protection Orders Under Title 13, Article 14

Civil protection orders are requested by a petitioner — a spouse, partner, neighbor, coworker, or anyone else who claims to need protection. They do not require a criminal charge, and a petitioner may seek one even when an MPO is already in place.

Temporary Orders: The Imminent Danger Requirement

Under C.R.S. § 13-14-104.5, a temporary civil protection order may be issued only if the judge or magistrate finds that an imminent danger exists to the person seeking protection. A temporary order is typically issued ex parte — without the respondent present — so the law requires that it be personally served and that the respondent be ordered to appear and show cause why it should not be made permanent.

Permanent Orders: Proof That the Conduct Will Continue

At the permanent order hearing under C.R.S. § 13-14-106, the court must find by a preponderance of the evidence that the respondent committed acts constituting grounds for the order and that, unless restrained, the respondent will continue to commit those acts or acts designed to intimidate or retaliate. Imminent danger is not required at this stage — but the forward-looking finding is. A single, isolated incident with no realistic likelihood of recurrence is a legitimate defense theme.

The civil process — from temporary order to permanent order — and the limits built into it.

Other limits written into the civil statutes are frequently overlooked:

  • Mutual orders are restricted. A court may not enter a mutual protection order for opposing parties unless each party independently meets its burden of proof — § 13-14-106(3).
  • Parenting terms yield. Provisions dealing with custody or parenting time terminate when a later order on the same subject is entered in the dissolution, custody, or juvenile case — § 13-14-108(1).
  • A permanent order is appealable. In In re Marriage of Wiggs, 2025 COA 10, the Court of Appeals held that a permanent protection order entered within a pending divorce case is a final, appealable order.

Modifying or Dismissing a Permanent Civil Protection Order

A permanent civil order can last indefinitely, but it is not necessarily permanent in the ordinary sense of the word. C.R.S. § 13-14-108 sets the rules, using the court’s JDF 397 motion form:

  • The two-year wait. A restrained party may not file a motion to modify or dismiss a permanent order until two years after the order issued or after the disposition of his or her last such motion. The protected party may seek modification at any time.
  • The new-conviction bar. If the restrained party is convicted of (or pleads guilty to) a new misdemeanor or felony against the protected person, the permanent order becomes non-modifiable on the restrained party’s motion.
  • Background check. The court will not consider the restrained party’s motion without a fingerprint-based criminal history check completed within 90 days before filing.
  • Burden and service. The moving party must personally serve the motion and prove by a preponderance that modification or dismissal is appropriate.
The ten statutory factors a court weighs under § 13-14-108(6).

A well-prepared motion addresses every one of the ten statutory factors with documentation: proof of compliance, completed treatment, the time elapsed, the absence of any new incidents, and changed living and working circumstances. Judges see many of these motions filed without evidence. The ones that succeed look like a trial notebook.

One of the most common — and most dangerous — misunderstandings is that if the protected person invites contact, there is no violation. In Hotsenpiller v. Morris, 2017 COA 95, the Court of Appeals rejected that argument. A protection order is an order of the court, not of the protected person, and only the court can modify it. The protected person’s assent is not an affirmative defense.

That said, the facts surrounding an invitation are not irrelevant. The court in Hotsenpiller recognized that the protected person’s conduct may bear on whether the defendant acted knowingly — a required element under § 18-6-803.5 — or on whether prohibited contact occurred at all. The lesson for anyone under an order is simple: if contact needs to happen, get the order modified first.

Hotsenpiller v. Morris: the protected person cannot waive the court’s order.

Protection Orders and Firearms

When a criminal MPO qualifies as an order described in federal law, § 18-1-1001(9) requires the court to order the defendant to relinquish firearms and ammunition and to file proof of relinquishment. Civil orders carry parallel duties under C.R.S. § 13-14-105.5. Federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(8), separately makes it a felony to possess a firearm while subject to a qualifying order — and in United States v. Rahimi, 602 U.S. 680 (2024), the U.S. Supreme Court upheld that prohibition as applied to a person a court has found to pose a credible threat. For a broader overview, see my guide to Colorado gun laws.

State relinquishment rules and federal law operate together — deadlines are short.

When the Order Is Violated: C.R.S. § 18-6-803.5

A person commits the crime of violation of a protection order when, after being personally served or otherwise acquiring actual knowledge of the order, he or she knowingly contacts or approaches a protected person, enters an excluded area, possesses a firearm in violation of the order, or violates another listed term.

Violating a criminal MPO is generally charged as a class 1 misdemeanor; violating a civil order is generally a class 2 misdemeanor on a first offense, with enhancement for prior convictions. A violation also routinely triggers bond revocation, new charges, and in domestic violence cases a sentence that must run consecutively. If the violation occurs while on supervision, it can also become a probation violation.

The defenses are real: lack of service or actual knowledge, ambiguity in the order’s terms, contact that falls outside the order’s scope, accidental or incidental encounters, and fabricated or exaggerated allegations made for leverage in a divorce or custody dispute. Each turns on careful, early investigation.

What to Do If You Are Restrained by a Colorado Protection Order

Six practical steps that protect your liberty and your case.
  • Read every term. Know exactly who is protected, which locations are excluded, and whether third-party or electronic contact is barred.
  • Do not respond to contact. Not a text, not a returned call, not a “like” on social media — even if the protected person reaches out first.
  • Preserve evidence. Save messages and call logs that show who initiated contact; they matter for a modification motion and for any violation defense.
  • Surrender firearms on time and file the required proof with the court.
  • Move to modify through counsel. A modification request is a hearing with consequences. Build the record for appeal.
  • Demand the required findings. If the order separates you from your children, insist that the court address compelling circumstances and less restrictive means on the record.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the alleged victim drop a mandatory protection order in Colorado?

No. A criminal MPO is an order of the court, not of the alleged victim. The protected person can ask the prosecutor to request a modification hearing, and the defendant can move to modify at any time, but only a judge can change or dismiss it.

How long does a mandatory protection order last in Colorado?

Until final disposition of the criminal case. If the case is dismissed or ends in acquittal, the order ends. If the defendant is sentenced, it generally lasts until the sentence — including any parole — is completed, unless the court modifies or dismisses it sooner.

Can a no-contact order keep me from my children?

It can, but when it does, Colorado appellate courts require the judge to find compelling circumstances and that no less restrictive means — such as supervised contact — would protect the child. People v. Zoller (2023) and People v. Manzanares (2025) set out that requirement.

When can I ask to dismiss a permanent civil protection order?

A restrained party generally must wait two years after the permanent order or after the last motion to modify or dismiss, must obtain a fingerprint-based background check within 90 days of filing, and must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that modification or dismissal is appropriate under the ten statutory factors.

If the protected person invites me over, is that a violation?

Yes, it can be. Hotsenpiller v. Morris (2017) held that the protected person’s consent is not a defense. Only the court can modify its order, so get the order changed before any contact occurs.

TALK TO A COLORADO PROTECTION ORDER DEFENSE LAWYER

If you are restrained by a mandatory protection order or a civil protection order — or charged with violating one — the limits described in this article may be the difference between losing contact with your family for years and getting your life back. H. Michael Steinberg has defended people in Denver and throughout the metro area for more than forty years, including in domestic violence, assault, and sex crime cases where protection orders are central. Review representative case results, read more on the Colorado Criminal Lawyer Blog, or contact the firm today.

Call 720-220-2277

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes and case law change; consult a licensed Colorado attorney about your specific situation. Law Office of H. Michael Steinberg, Denver, Colorado.

Client Reviews

"Mr. Steinberg provided my family with expert handling of my son's case. He took extra time understand the case, to consult with us during the pretrial proceedings, and to support him for a plea agreement. Mr. Steinberg is very...

Tanya Witt

"I found myself in criminal trouble, that I wasn't guilty of and thanks to Mr. Steinberg's dedication and hard work, right before we we're looking at having to continue on to trial level Mr. Steinberg was able to use his vast knowledge...

Josh

"Working with Michael Steinberg was a wonderful experience. Truly people need to know that he is a expert in what he does. His personality is compassionate, intellectual, and down to earth. I glean that Michael is fun to be around. In...

Renee Taylor

Mr. Steinberg, It has been an honor working with you. I very much appreciated your style, demeanor, patience, and determination. I was well instructed in every step of the court process, and I felt that I received excellent guidance...

Anonymous

Exclusive Criminal Defense Services

Fill out the contact form or call us at 303-627-7777 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message