The Crime of Insurance Fraud in Colorado

One of the less prosecuted crimes in Colorado – although that is changing – is the crime of insurance fraud. Although each jurisdiction in Colorado has the right to investigate and bring charges of insurance fraud – the task often falls to the Colorado State Attorney General’s Fraud Unit. This webpage addresses the prosecution of these cases.

Concerning the Colorado Department of Law Insurance Fraud Unit

The Insurance Fraud Unit (“Unit”) is part of the Department of Law’s Financial Fraud Unit within the Criminal Justice Section of the office. The Unit investigates and prosecutes criminal offenses relating to insurance fraud. Typical cases involve theft and forgeries. The Unit consists of two attorneys, four investigators, one paralegal, and half of the time of one administrative assistant.

Fraudulent insurance claims referrals from the Colorado Division of Insurance increased by 54% in 2010, up from 527 in 2009, 337 in 2008 and 272 in 2007 as a result of the poor economy in the past few years.

During 2011, the Unit processed 579 referrals of potential criminal cases relating to insurance fraud. Most of these referrals were made to the Unit by the Colorado Division of Insurance. Other sources of referrals were law enforcement agencies and the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB).

The Unit often works large complex cases both internally and in conjunction with other law enforcement agencies. The Unit – each year – conducts several large investigations and uses the statewide grand jury to investigate and indict individuals and companies they pursue. State District Attorneys – without the same extensive funding sources – will refer the larger cases to the States Attorney General. A few counties, notably Arapahoe – Douglas, Denver, and Jefferson County have economic crime units that have the capacity to take on major complex crimes.

In 2011, the Unit opened 96 new investigations. The Unit filed a total of twenty-nine new cases in Colorado courts. The cases were filed in Adams, Arapahoe, Denver, Douglas, El Paso, Morgan, Montrose and Weld Counties. Eight of these cases were initiated by indictments issued by the Colorado Statewide Grand Jury; the other twenty-one were direct filed by Complaint and Information.

Through a joint effort with the Attorney General’s Auto Theft Unit, the Colorado Attorney General’s office shut down an insurance-fraud ring that defrauded insurance companies using staged automobile accidents and other fraudulent insurance claims.

The Unit most often charges crimes such as theft, forgery and violations as well as making extensive use of the Colorado Organized Crime Control Act (a class 2 felony),

Here are some examples of the types of insurance fraud cases they prosecute and publish online:

Trenton Stone

was charged in 2007 with both working as an accountant while drawing full medical disability pay and embezzling about $250,000 from one of his clients. He had worked for the state of Colorado as an accountant at the time he filed his disability claim. The case went to a jury trial in May of 2009, in Arapahoe County District Court, and the defendant was convicted of felony theft.

Susan Weiss-Nakash

was indicted by the statewide grand jury in May of 2009 for two counts of felony theft relating to mortgage fraud. Weiss-Nakash used her mortgage company, Miracle Mortgage, to create fraudulent loans to illegally obtain monies from both a lender and a title insurance company. She then deposited those funds into accounts for her personal use. She pled guilty to both counts in December and was sentenced to ten years of probation, 25 hours of community service and ordered to pay restitution in the amount of $189,100.65 to the defrauded companies.

C.P. Fortney, Terry Robinson and Mary Catherine Cross

were indicted by the statewide grand jury in May of 2009 and charged with multiple counts of bribery and theft. Fortney was a used car salesman, Robinson was a field claims adjuster, and Cross was an in-house claims adjuster. Fortney paid bribes to Robinson to write estimates showing that wrecked vehicles were total losses, and paid bribes to Cross to arrange to sell the cars to him without salvage titles. Fortney repaired the vehicles and sold them to members of the public without disclosing that the vehicles had been rebuilt from salvage. Robinson and Cross have entered into plea bargains and have agreed to testify against Fortney.

What Now?

The Denver Colorado law firm of H. Michael Steinberg has built and launched five different websites that provide valuable online legal resources to current and potential clients. The sites offer helpful information to remove some of the fear and uncertainty from the legal process, including basic information on Colorado criminal laws.

Our site has been designed to provide potential and existing clients with the critical information they need to help them understand how we will bring their matter under control and guide them through the entire legal process. It is our belief that the personal attention we provide will be illustrated by the information provided there.

Website visitors learn how – after nearly three decades of Colorado criminal law practice – the experienced Colorado criminal law attorney H. Michael Steinberg can assist them with their legal issue. The firm has developed a reputation for maintaining high ethical standards while aggressively representing clients throughout Denver and the Front Range of Colorado in Criminal legal matters.

Whether the consequences are of the most serious nature or seemingly minor, facing criminal charges can be a frightening experience, potentially putting your reputation and even your freedom in jeopardy. With more than 38 years of experience in the field of criminal defense, law firm principal H. Michael Steinberg has the skills and background to effectively protect your constitutional rights.

Since founding his practice in 1982, Denver Colorado criminal defense attorney H. Michael Steinberg has appeared in state and federal trial courts throughout the region, earning the respect of local prosecutors, judges, and attorneys alike.

Client Reviews
"Mr. Steinberg provided my family with expert handling of my son's case. He took extra time understand the case, to consult with us during the pretrial proceedings, and to support him for a plea agreement. Mr. Steinberg is very knowledge about the law and very professional. He guided us in achieving the best possible outcome for my son. If I am ever in need of law services again, I will certainly have Mr. Steinberg handle my case. l also highly recommend his services to anyone that might be in need of an excellent defense attorney!" Tanya Witt
"I found myself in criminal trouble, that I wasn't guilty of and thanks to Mr. Steinberg's dedication and hard work, right before we we're looking at having to continue on to trial level Mr. Steinberg was able to use his vast knowledge of the law and his many respected years in the system to find a way to show my innocence. After a very unsure and somewhat difficult time for me, this very skilled and knowledgeable attorney was able to find the right path to take to reach a dismissal in my case. For that I can't tell you how much I appreciate his representation and his excellent understanding and helpful personality. He's a great man and an even better attorney but don't misunderstand him, he is an attorney not a therapist. Thanks H." Josh
"Working with Michael Steinberg was a wonderful experience. Truly people need to know that he is a expert in what he does. His personality is compassionate, intellectual, and down to earth. I glean that Michael is fun to be around. In the time I worked with him, it was a pleasure to be around him. As for my case, the outcome was amazing and couldn’t be better. He has made my life more manageable because of the outcome of my case. I’ve worked with other lawyers in the Denver area. He is superior to them all. If you’re in need of a lawyer and you come across Mr. Steinberg look no further he’s going to be the one you need. Thank you again Michael." Renee Taylor
Mr. Steinberg, It has been an honor working with you. I very much appreciated your style, demeanor, patience, and determination. I was well instructed in every step of the court process, and I felt that I received excellent guidance and timely information regarding my case. You have been extremely thoughtful with your time, and I was very impressed with your sensitivity in responding to my requests. Thank you. Anonymous