Police Pressured a Witness to Implicate You — Can the Statement Be Suppressed?

THE LAW OFFICE OF H. MICHAEL STEINBERG

Colorado Criminal Defense • Denver, Colorado • 720-220-2277

What People v. Perez, 2026 COA 72 means when the evidence against you came from someone else’s interrogation.

By H. Michael Steinberg, Colorado Criminal Defense Lawyer — Denver, Colorado

A client sits across from me and says, “My co-defendant only turned on me because the detectives scared him. They told him he’d go to prison for life unless he gave them my name. That has to be illegal, right?”

It is one of the most common questions I hear, and the honest answer is more complicated than most people expect. Pressure on a witness — even heavy pressure — does not automatically make that witness’s statement inadmissible.

A favorable plea offer does not automatically do it either.

On September 24, 2026, the Colorado Court of Appeals spelled out exactly what the defense has to show in People v. Perez, 2026 COA 72, and the bar is real.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • In Perez, the Colorado Court of Appeals adopted, for the first time in a published Colorado decision, a framework for claims that police coerced an incriminating statement from someone other than the defendant.
  • You cannot assert the witness’s Fifth Amendment privilege — it belongs to the witness. Your claim is a due process / fair-trial claim.
  • The burden is on you. You must identify facts showing improper coercion and show that it affected the reliability of the evidence presented at trial.
  • A judge need not hold an evidentiary hearing if the defense fails to identify a genuine factual dispute — for example, when the witness never claims coercion and recorded interviews show none.
  • General offers of leniency and plea deals requiring truthful testimony are usually credibility issues for the jury, not grounds for suppression.

What Happened in People v. Perez

The case arose from a Jefferson County homicide. According to the opinion, Ricardo Gonzalez Perez killed Gail Wilson in the home they shared with Wilson’s daughter, Savannah, and Perez’s friend, Griffith. Savannah saw the killing; Griffith saw the body afterward. The three concealed the body and evidence and reported Wilson missing (Colorado Lawyer case summary).

Savannah and Griffith first told police a cover story. Later, while in custody and represented by their own lawyers, they gave recorded statements implicating Perez. Each eventually pleaded guilty to accessory-type offenses in exchange for truthful testimony, with recommended probation. (For background on accessory liability, see What Is an Accessory to a Crime in Colorado? C.R.S. § 18-8-105.)

Before trial, Perez moved to suppress both witnesses’ statements as coerced by “promises for leniency” and asked for an evidentiary hearing. The trial judge reviewed the extensive record, heard argument, and denied the motion without taking testimony — finding the witnesses were “incentivized, but they weren’t coerced.” Perez was convicted of first degree murder and related charges and was sentenced to life without parole.

A three-judge division (Judge Johnson writing, with Judges Freyre and Berger concurring) affirmed.

“General offers of leniency do not amount to coercion.”

— People v. Perez, 2026 COA 72 (Johnson, J.)

The New Colorado Framework

Colorado appellate courts had not previously addressed this question in a published opinion, so the division borrowed from federal and California decisions, including the Tenth Circuit’s United States v. Gonzales, 164 F.3d 1285 (10th Cir. 1999), the Fifth Circuit’s United States v. Merkt, 794 F.2d 950 (5th Cir. 1986), and the California Supreme Court’s People v. Badgett, 895 P.2d 877 (Cal. 1995) and People v. Clark, 372 P.3d 811 (Cal. 2016).

AUTHORITY: People v. Perez, 2026 COA 72 — The Framework

  • Nature of the claim. The Fifth Amendment privilege is personal to the witness (United States v. Nobles, 422 U.S. 225 (1975)). A defendant challenging a third party’s statement raises a due process claim.
  • Burden. Unlike a challenge to the defendant’s own statement — where the prosecution must prove voluntariness (Lego v. Twomey, 404 U.S. 477 (1972)) — the defendant carries the burden.
  • Improper coercion. The defendant must identify facts showing improper coercion by law enforcement.
  • Reliability. The defendant must show the coercion would actually affect the reliability of the evidence presented at trial, depriving the defendant of a fair trial.
  • Hearing. A court may, but is not always required to, hold an evidentiary hearing. Without a genuine factual dispute, a hearing is unlikely to be needed.
The four-step framework from People v. Perez, 2026 COA 72.

Five Questions That Are Easy to Confuse

The most useful thing Perez does is force a careful separation of issues that clients — and sometimes lawyers — tend to blend together. Each of the following is a different legal question with a different burden and a different remedy.

Five different questions — not one.

1. Coercion of Your Own Statement

When police coerce you, the rules are the most protective. Under the Due Process Clause and article II, section 25 of the Colorado Constitution, an involuntary statement cannot be used against you. Once you make an initial showing that your statement was involuntary, the prosecution must prove voluntariness by a preponderance of the evidence (People v. Zadran, 2013 CO 69M; People v. Ramadon, 2013 CO 68).

There must be coercive police conduct — a defendant’s own mental state alone is not enough (Colorado v. Connelly, 479 U.S. 157 (1986)). But threats and promises can qualify. In Ramadon, the Colorado Supreme Court upheld suppression where a detective exploited the suspect’s fear of deportation, and in People v. Springsted, 2016 COA 188, a division found later interviews involuntary after cumulative threats, promises, and psychological pressure. I discuss this in more depth in What Happens When the Police Make Promises? and Understanding the Miranda Rule.

2. Coercion of a Witness or Codefendant

This is where Perez changes the analysis. You have no standing to assert the witness’s privilege against self-incrimination. What you do have is your own right to a fair trial.

That right is violated when the government coerces a witness into a false or unreliable statement and then uses it against you — the Tenth Circuit has recognized exactly that in Clanton v. Cooper, 129 F.3d 1147 (10th Cir. 1997) and Gonzales.

The focus, however, is not on whether the witness was treated unfairly. It is on whether the evidence you face at trial is unreliable. California’s Badgett line of cases, which Perez followed, makes the point sharply: an allegation that pressure produced an involuntary statement before trial is not enough by itself. The question is the reliability of what the jury will actually hear.

The question is not whether the witness was treated badly. It is whether police misconduct produced evidence so unreliable that you cannot get a fair trial.

3. Ordinary Plea Negotiations

Prosecutors routinely offer co-defendants reduced charges in exchange for testimony. Perez confirms that this is not, standing alone, coercion. Every plea agreement involves some compulsion, but an agreement that requires only full and truthful testimony is valid.

In Perez, the witnesses were represented by counsel, their proffer agreement disclaimed promises of leniency, and the defense identified no specific promise made to either witness at the time of the statements.

The line is crossed when a deal pressures a witness to deliver a particular story rather than the truth. California courts — whose framework Perez adopted — have distinguished agreements that bind a witness to repeat an earlier version of events from agreements requiring only truthful testimony. That distinction is worth examining in any cooperation agreement. See The Nature and Law of Plea Agreements and Plea Bargaining — Am I Safe When Talking to the District Attorney?.

4. Credibility Arguments for the Jury

Losing a suppression motion is not the end of the issue. A witness who changed stories after being offered probation on a murder-related case has an obvious motive to please the prosecution, and the jury is entitled to hear all of it. The prosecution must disclose cooperation deals and promises (Giglio v. United States, 405 U.S. 150 (1972)) and may not let false testimony about them stand uncorrected (Napue v. Illinois, 360 U.S. 264 (1959)).

In Perez, the plea deals reportedly would not take effect until after the defendant’s trial — a fact a defense lawyer would want every juror to understand. The trial court actually viewed differences between the two witnesses’ accounts as a sign they were not rehearsed. Cross-examination is where that inference gets tested. F

or more, see The Right to Confront Witnesses, What Lawyers Look For to See If a Witness Is Lying, and Motivations for False Allegations in Colorado Criminal Cases.

5. The Factual Showing Required to Get a Hearing

When a defendant challenges his own statement, a factual dispute is almost built in: the defendant says it was coerced, the prosecution says it was voluntary. Perez holds that the same is not true for a third-party witness. If the witness does not claim coercion, the defense must allege specific facts creating a genuine dispute — and the court does not have to accept those allegations if the record shows the statement was voluntary.

The division compared the facts to Merkt, where more aggressive agent conduct had still been found insufficient, and concluded the conduct in Perez was milder. Because the interviews were videotaped, the appellate court watched them itself and stood in the same position as the trial judge. A conclusory motion stood no chance against that record.

WHAT A STRONGER MOTION MIGHT IDENTIFY

  • A recantation, sworn statement, or credible account from the witness describing threats or specific promises.
  • Unrecorded contact before the recording began — “pre-interviews,” phone calls, or jail visits that are not on video.
  • Threats directed at the witness’s children, spouse, or immigration status, or promises tied to what the witness says rather than whether it is true.
  • Detectives feed facts that later appear in the witness’s account.
  • Witness vulnerabilities — youth, intoxication, mental illness, or withdrawal — exploited during questioning.
  • Contradictions between the coerced account and the physical or digital evidence.

Building that record requires aggressive investigation and full discovery of every interview, note, and agreement. See Making Discovery Under Colorado Law and Understanding Prosecutorial Misconduct.

Side-by-Side Comparison

IssueLegal SourceWho Bears the BurdenRemedy
Your own coerced statementDue process; Colo. Const. art. II, § 25Prosecution must prove voluntarinessSuppression
Coerced witness / codefendantYour due process right to a fair trialDefense must allege specific factsExclusion only if reliability and fairness are compromised
Plea deal for truthful testimonyPlea-bargaining law; due processGenerally lawfulDisclosure and cross-examination
Witness credibilityConfrontation; rules of evidenceJury decidesImpeachment at trial
Evidentiary hearingPerez frameworkDefense must show a genuine disputeHearing may be denied on the record

What Perez Does Not Decide

Perez does not hold that a coerced witness statement can never be excluded. It holds that the defense must do the work of proving it.

A case with a witness who recants, unrecorded threats, or a deal that rewards a particular story may come out very differently. The opinion also leaves room for the defense to attack the same facts at trial even after losing the motion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I suppress a co-defendant’s statement because police threatened him?

Possibly, but not just because there was pressure. Under Perez, you must show specific facts of improper police coercion and that it affected the reliability of the evidence used at your trial.

Is a plea deal for testimony considered coercion?

No. An agreement requiring only full and truthful testimony is valid. A deal that pressures the witness to repeat a particular version of events raises a more serious question.

Will the judge automatically hold a hearing on my motion?

No. If the witness does not claim coercion and the record — such as a recorded interview — shows none, the court may deny the motion without an evidentiary hearing.

If the motion fails, can my lawyer still raise the pressure at trial?

Yes. Deals, promises, and changed stories are classic grounds for cross-examination, and the prosecution must disclose them.

Talk to an Experienced Colorado Criminal Defense Lawyer

If the case against you depends on a witness who changed his story after police pressure or a cooperation deal, the time to build the record is now — before the motions deadline. H. Michael Steinberg has defended Colorado criminal cases for over forty years. Call 720-220-2277 or contact the Law Office of H. Michael Steinberg for a free consultation. More analysis is available on the Colorado Criminal Lawyer Blog.

DISCLAIMER

This article is for general educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law changes, slip opinions may be modified, and every case depends on its specific facts. Consult a qualified Colorado criminal defense attorney about your situation.

Client Reviews

"Mr. Steinberg provided my family with expert handling of my son's case. He took extra time understand the case, to consult with us during the pretrial proceedings, and to support him for a plea agreement. Mr. Steinberg is very...

Tanya Witt

"I found myself in criminal trouble, that I wasn't guilty of and thanks to Mr. Steinberg's dedication and hard work, right before we we're looking at having to continue on to trial level Mr. Steinberg was able to use his vast knowledge...

Josh

"Working with Michael Steinberg was a wonderful experience. Truly people need to know that he is a expert in what he does. His personality is compassionate, intellectual, and down to earth. I glean that Michael is fun to be around. In...

Renee Taylor

Mr. Steinberg, It has been an honor working with you. I very much appreciated your style, demeanor, patience, and determination. I was well instructed in every step of the court process, and I felt that I received excellent guidance...

Anonymous

Exclusive Criminal Defense Services

Fill out the contact form or call us at 303-627-7777 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message